Board Eyes Charging Tax-Exempt Properties For Storm Sewer Projects

Caledonia's Village Board discussed how they fund storm sewer projects, which they currently have on the property tax bills. But they want to make one village-wide district where all property owners pay.

The Village may ask tax-exempt property owners – including churches, schools and non-profit organizations – to pay for storm sewer projects.

Currently the funds the projects through a tax levy, but they are looking at establishing a user fee that all property owners pay to fund capital, maintenance, operational and compliance-based projects.

The Village Board approved the concept and has asked a Village staff member to put together a draft request for a proposal to fund a study, which has an estimated cost of $25,000. However, the details would still need approval from the Village Board.

Tony Bunkelman, assistant engineer for the Village, explained that the Village currently has two storm sewer districts, the Lake Michigan District and the Root River District. The Lake Michigan District has 5,633 parcels spread over 5,727 acres and the Root River District has 5,570 parcels spread over 21,800 acres, but 392 parcels are tax exempt and do not fund the district at all.

“Both have a tax levy, but only the properties that pay property taxes fund the district and none of your tax-exempt properties pay into the district in any way shape or form,” Bunkelman said. “Property owners’ pay based on the assessed value of their property. But to my knowledge there is no correlation between assessed value and storm water run-off generated.”

Schools, churches, and property owned by non-profit organizations are some of the largest contributors to water run-off, Bunkelman explained.

“Some of your churches and schools are paved corner to corner and that creates an impervious surface, and they don’t pay into the system,” he said.

Bunkelman proposed replacing the current tax levy and having all property owners pay a user fee based on an equivalent residential unit (ERU) formula.

“Since all properties generate storm water run-off it makes sense,” he said.

Property owners living in the Lake Michigan District currently pay about $85 a year on the storm sewer portion of their tax bill, but if the Village goes to an equivalent residential unit system and requires all properties to pay the user fee, they’ll see that amount reduced significantly.

However, property owners living in the Root River District will likely see a fee larger than the a mount they pay on their property tax bill.

“That increase was going to happen anyway though because there just isn’t enough money coming in to fund those projects,” he said. “But this way there’s more property to spread it over.”

There is also another drawback. User fees aren’t tax deductible while some property owners may have been claiming that storm sewer portion of their tax levy as a deduction on their taxes even though they aren’t supposed to claim, Bunkelman said.

“But I believe this is a fair way of calculating storm water use fees,” he said. “The larger properties have more impervious surface, and they create a larger demand on the system so the larger their fees should be.”

Village Board member Lee Wishau asked Bunkelman what he hoped to accomplish with the study and asked him to come up with a draft RFP before sending it out.

“This study would come up with a way to calculate the ERU and have it still be fair,” Bunkelman said.

Village Board member Tom Weatherston also asked about whether the two districts could be combined into one.

“I do believe the goal of this Board is to combine the districts and have a uniform fee for the entire Village,” he said.

Jay Warner June 20, 2012 at 04:42 AM
1) Tax exempt properties, including churches, can be expected to kick in for the fire & police protection they receive. (The insurance they pay presumes that they have fire protection, as they should.) 2) Those who live in a storm sewer district presently pay, regardless of the amount of storm water they pass out of their boundaries. A 1 inch flood in your basement is almost as damaging as a 6 inch flood. Trust me - I've had both. So non-profits could be reasonably expected to kick in for storm sewer water protection, just like everyone else in a district. Call it a tax or a fee; if you live there, then you get the benefit.
Jay Warner June 20, 2012 at 04:48 AM
Looking forward: If the Board, or anyone, wants to change the storm sewer drainage to a fee based on building size, then it should include incentives for people to NOT dump storm water off their lots. Make the fee based on the amount of impervious surface (size of building, size of paved parking lot) BUT reduced by things that would reduce storm water runoff. Such as rain gardens, permeable paving, adjacent wetlands to filter & slow runoff. Some of these can be done with present parking lots and buildings, for not much cost. All that 'green' stuff can sharply reduce runoff and the problems that causes. And improve water quality in our Lake and River. By putting in this sort of stuff, people would reduce the cost of storm sewer control & management. If that saving were in the basic fee, the payoff to the citizen would be realized right away. PLUS, as Caledonia grows, the storm drainage problem would not grow with it. Go check out the rain garden at the EAst Side fire station. Works well, looks nice.
JW June 20, 2012 at 03:22 PM
It is only fair and right that they contribute to the services they receive. Tax exempt makes sense for perhaps a break in property taxes and saving on sales taxes... but it shouldnt get to the point of free where it means other tax payers subsidize them receiving the services completely for free. If that is how it works or has always worked, then yeah, that should be changed. Again, I dont think it needs to be black and white... they can play a mid-level contribution and starting to pay fees for services is one way to accomplish that.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something